Old Fashioned Stuffed Peppers (Better Than Mom’s)

The first frost hit southeastern Wisconsin last week.  I really can’t complain.  The rest of the state, unprotected by Lake Michigan, lost tender crops much earlier.  As a last farewell to summer, I decided to stuff the final bell peppers (using some of my grass-fed beef) for a lovely welcome-to-fall dinner.

My mother used to make stuffed peppers—but in my pepper hating youth, I shunned them and never collected the recipe.  So I went out to the internet, did some combining and a little innovating and prepared the recipe below.

When I set out dinner, the kids looked at the peppers skeptically, but came around at the first bite.  Indeed, they were better than I remembered.  I liked the flavor boost from the tomato paste in the filling and thought the dill was a great touch (it is common in stuffed pepper recipes, but I don’t think Mom used it).  Next year I think I’ll stuff some grape leaves too!

If you are still lucky enough to have bell peppers, why not give this a try.  Then pull up an ottoman, wrap yourself in a quilt and welcome the changing seasons.  Happy November!

Old-Fashioned Stuffed Peppers


  • 8-12 peppers (depending on size), tops, seeds and interior ribs removed
  • 1 T canola oil
  • 4 cloves garlic, minced (or crushed in garlic press)
  • 1 onion, chopped
  • 1.5 lb ground beef
  • 1/2 c fresh parsley, chopped
  • 1 t salt
  • 1 6 oz jar tomato paste
  • 1 T dill
  • 2 c cooked rice
  • 1 jar of cook canned pasta sauce (or homemade) for topping


  1. Sautee garlic and onion in oil until tender.
  2. Add ground beef and cook until browned.  Drain off excess fat.
  3. Add parsley, dill, tomato paste and salt and blend well.
  4. Combine meat mixture with cooked rice and stuff into peppers
  5. Cover with pasta sauce (I used a good canned organic like Seeds of Change or Muir Glen) and bake at 350 for 45-60 minutes until filling is heated through (an instant-read meat thermometer works great for this) and the pepper is tender.

Tip:  Make more stuffed peppers than you need and freeze the extras individually.  Later, you can take out just the amount you need for a super easy dinner.

Extra tip: If you are feeding a confirmed pepper hater, you can also stuff tomatoes.  Make sure the filling is hot when you insert it, then reduce the cooking time because the tomato will collapse if baked too long.  Add any stuffed tomatoes to your baking pan later–after the peppers are partially cooked.

7 thoughts on “Old Fashioned Stuffed Peppers (Better Than Mom’s)

  1. Pingback: Quinoa Stuffed Peppers « Art of Natural Living

  2. Louise

    We stuff a lot of peppers around here. As you say, Inger, they are GREAT to have in the freezer at all times. Dressed up or down for a comfy meal for family or guests, they are so versatile. I must try the dill though. I usually make them the same way each time. Although, last week when I made them I sliced the peppers into rings and stuffed each ring individually. It worked great since it is only Marion and I “stuffing” ourselves with them!

    Thanks for sharing…

  3. Barbara

    These look great and I love the idea of freezing leftovers for another meal. When you’re cooking for one or two, this is a real plus.
    And if they’re better than mom’s, they have to be delicious. I don’t know about your mom, but mine was a super cook!

  4. Tammy

    I have so many green peppers in my fridge! These were on for Monday night and we ended up eating something else so I am planning them for the weekend.

    1. Inger Wilkerson

      I am both happy and sad when late fall comes to Wisconsin–sad because we’ll have no more peppers, etc but glad for some free space in the fridge! It would be a very different rhythm in Arizona (we loved foraging for oranges at ASU when we had snow up here)!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.